Make a payment

Energy Insights

Energy Procurement Consultant: Broker or DIY?

Energy procurement consultant discussing business energy buying options

Energy Procurement Consultant: Broker or DIY?

Key takeaways:

  • An energy procurement consultant can provide strategic advice, market analysis, tender management and contract support.
  • An energy broker generally focuses on sourcing and comparing retailer offers, which can suit businesses seeking a streamlined procurement process.
  • DIY energy procurement gives businesses direct control but requires internal expertise, market knowledge and sufficient time.
  • The cheapest headline electricity rate does not necessarily represent the best overall contract.
  • Businesses should consider consumption patterns, contract terms, risk tolerance, sustainability objectives and future operational requirements before buying energy.
  • The right procurement approach depends on organisational size, energy spend, internal resources and contract complexity.

Introduction

Buying electricity for a business can look straightforward until you start comparing pricing structures, contract periods, network charges, demand costs, renewable energy options and contractual conditions.

Australian businesses generally have three broad ways to approach the task: engage an energy procurement consultant, use an energy broker, or manage procurement internally.

Each model can work. However, the right choice depends on the complexity of your energy requirements, internal capabilities and the amount of risk your organisation is prepared to manage.

An energy procurement consultant typically takes a broader strategic view of procurement, while a broker may concentrate more heavily on obtaining and comparing retailer offers. Meanwhile, a do-it-yourself approach keeps the entire process within your organisation.

Importantly, Australian energy customers can face different retail offers with different prices, conditions and tariff structures. The Australian Energy Regulator encourages eligible customers to compare offers rather than assuming a standing offer provides the lowest available price. Australian Energy Regulator (AER)

Understanding the differences between the three procurement models can help your business decide how much expertise and support it needs.

Energy Procurement Consultant, Broker or DIY: The Key Differences

Although consultants and brokers can perform overlapping functions, their scope and commercial arrangements may differ between providers.

ApproachTypical roleKey advantageKey consideration
Energy procurement consultantStrategic procurement, market analysis, tendering and contract adviceBroader strategic supportConsulting costs and scope should be understood
Energy brokerSources and compares retailer offersEfficient access to competing offersUnderstand remuneration and retailer coverage
DIY procurementInternal team manages the processFull internal controlRequires expertise, resources and market knowledge

Therefore, businesses should look beyond job titles. Before appointing an external provider, clarify exactly what services they provide, how they are paid and which retailers or products they can access.

1. Using an Energy Procurement Consultant

An energy procurement consultant helps businesses develop and execute an energy purchasing strategy rather than simply obtaining a price from a retailer.

The process can begin with an assessment of historical consumption, peak demand, existing contractual arrangements and future energy requirements. The consultant can then help determine an appropriate procurement structure and take suitable offers to market.

What does an energy procurement consultant do?

Depending on the engagement, services may include analysing interval and billing data, developing procurement strategies, conducting competitive tenders, evaluating retailer proposals, assessing contractual terms and monitoring energy markets.

Consultants may also help organisations examine renewable electricity options, Power Purchase Agreements and other longer-term procurement structures.

This broader perspective matters because electricity contracts involve more than the advertised usage rate. Existing Energy Action material similarly highlights the importance of assessing consumption patterns, comparing contract types and examining conditions such as demand charges, exit provisions and renewal clauses. 

When does a consultant make sense?

An energy procurement consultant may be particularly useful for organisations with substantial electricity expenditure, multiple sites or complicated load profiles.

The model can also suit businesses that lack specialist internal energy-market expertise or need to coordinate procurement with sustainability and risk-management objectives.

However, businesses should still understand the consultant's service scope and fee model before proceeding.

2. Using an Energy Broker

An energy broker acts as an intermediary between a business and energy retailers.

Typically, the broker collects information about the organisation's energy requirements and approaches retailers for offers. The broker can then present available options and assist with the contracting process.

Why businesses use energy brokers

Convenience is one of the main attractions. Instead of contacting multiple retailers individually, a business can use one intermediary to coordinate quotations and comparisons.

This can make procurement considerably easier for organisations without dedicated energy teams.

Furthermore, comparing competing offers is an important part of procurement. Energy Action's existing guidance on forward electricity contracting emphasises obtaining multiple offers and examining pricing structures and contract terms rather than automatically accepting the first proposal. 

Questions to ask an energy broker

Businesses should establish how the broker is remunerated, which retailers are included in the tender and whether there are any commercial relationships that could affect the available options.

They should also ask whether the broker provides strategic advice beyond price comparison.

This distinction matters because a competitive price today does not automatically mean the contract provides the best outcome over its entire term.

3. Buying Business Energy Yourself

The third option is DIY procurement.

Under this model, employees within the organisation analyse energy requirements, contact retailers, compare proposals, negotiate terms and manage contract renewal internally.

The greatest advantage is control. Your organisation owns the process and communicates directly with retailers.

Additionally, there are no external consultancy or brokerage costs associated with running the procurement exercise.

However, those advantages need to be weighed against the internal resources required.

What DIY energy procurement involves

A strong internal procurement process should include reviewing historical consumption, understanding the load profile, defining contract requirements, approaching multiple retailers and comparing offers on consistent assumptions.

The team also needs to examine contract length, pricing mechanisms, termination conditions, renewable energy requirements and other commercial provisions.

Timing can matter as well. Wholesale market conditions contribute to retail electricity costs, meaning the commercial environment can change between procurement exercises. The AER's 2026–27 Default Market Offer determination, for example, identified lower wholesale electricity costs and reduced spot-price volatility among factors contributing to lower small-business standing-offer prices in relevant regions. Australian Energy Regulator (AER)

Consequently, DIY procurement requires more than requesting three quotations and selecting the lowest number.

Energy Procurement Consultant Versus Broker Versus DIY

The three approaches become easier to compare when viewed against common business requirements.

ConsiderationConsultantBrokerDIY
Internal workloadLow to moderateLowHigh
Strategic adviceTypically highVariesDepends on internal expertise
Retailer tenderingUsuallyUsuallyManaged internally
Market analysisTypically includedVariesManaged internally
Contract analysisTypically detailedVariesManaged internally
Internal controlHigh with adviser supportModerate to highHighest
Best suited toComplex or strategic procurementBusinesses seeking tender supportBusinesses with strong internal capability

These distinctions are general rather than absolute. Some brokers provide extensive advisory services, while consultant service models also vary significantly.

Therefore, businesses should compare the actual scope offered rather than choosing solely according to whether a provider calls itself a consultant or broker.

How to Choose the Right Business Energy Procurement Approach

Start by examining your organisation rather than the market.

Consider your annual electricity expenditure, number of sites, consumption profile and available internal expertise. Then assess how important contract flexibility, budget certainty and renewable energy objectives are to the organisation.

A relatively straightforward business with capable procurement staff may be comfortable running a retailer comparison internally. In contrast, a multi-site organisation with significant electricity consumption may require deeper market analysis and contract modelling.

Renewable energy objectives can add another layer of complexity. For example, businesses considering long-term PPAs need to assess pricing structures, contract length, supply arrangements and risk exposure. Existing Energy Action guidance highlights these factors when assessing renewable energy PPAs.

Do not compare offers on price alone

A low headline rate can attract attention, but the overall commercial outcome depends on the complete agreement.

Businesses should examine contract duration, tariff structures, demand charges, environmental products, payment provisions, termination clauses and renewal conditions.

Moreover, future consumption matters. Expansion, electrification, onsite solar, batteries or operational changes can alter the amount and timing of electricity your business purchases.

The strongest procurement decision is therefore one that fits the organisation's expected energy profile rather than simply producing the lowest initial quote.

Why Energy Procurement Expertise Can Matter

Australia's energy market continues to change. Retail prices reflect several components, including wholesale electricity, network costs, environmental costs and retail costs. Australian Energy Regulator (AER)

For eligible small businesses, regulated standing offers can provide a safety net and comparison point. However, the AER notes that the Default Market Offer may not be the cheapest option available and encourages customers to explore competing market offers. Australian Energy Regulator (AER)

Larger organisations can face considerably more complicated purchasing decisions.

As consumption and contract complexity increase, procurement becomes increasingly connected with financial risk management, operational planning and sustainability strategy. Consequently, organisations need to decide whether those responsibilities belong internally or whether specialist external expertise can add value.

Conclusion

There is no single procurement model that suits every organisation.

A broker can simplify retailer comparisons and tendering. DIY procurement can provide direct control for organisations with sufficient internal expertise. Meanwhile, an energy procurement consultant can provide broader strategic support when contracts, market exposure or organisational requirements become more complex.

Whichever approach you choose, successful procurement starts with understanding your consumption, objectives and risk tolerance before entering the market.

Energy Action helps Australian organisations navigate energy procurement with market insights, procurement expertise and solutions designed around individual business requirements. To explore how professional procurement support could help your organisation manage energy costs, contract risk and future energy strategy, visit Energy Action.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What does an energy procurement consultant do?

An energy procurement consultant helps businesses plan and manage the process of purchasing electricity or gas. Depending on the engagement, this can include analysing consumption, developing procurement strategies, running retailer tenders, comparing contracts and providing market insights. The objective is to help the organisation make a procurement decision that reflects its commercial requirements and risk profile rather than focusing solely on the headline price.

2. What is the difference between an energy consultant and an energy broker?

The roles can overlap, so businesses should assess the services of individual providers rather than relying entirely on labels. Generally, an energy broker focuses on sourcing and comparing retailer offers, whereas an energy procurement consultant may provide broader strategic, analytical and contract support. However, some brokers offer extensive consulting services, making it important to clarify scope and remuneration before appointing a provider.

3. Can a business manage energy procurement itself?

Yes. Businesses with suitable expertise and sufficient resources can approach retailers, evaluate offers and negotiate contracts internally. However, the internal team needs to understand consumption data, tariff structures, contract conditions and market risks to make meaningful comparisons.

4. How should businesses compare energy offers?

Businesses should compare the total commercial structure rather than focusing only on a quoted electricity rate. Contract length, demand charges, tariff structures, termination provisions, renewable energy requirements and expected consumption can all affect the outcome. Using consistent assumptions across competing offers makes the comparison more meaningful.

5. When should a business consider an energy procurement consultant?

Professional support may become particularly valuable when a business has significant energy expenditure, multiple sites, complex consumption patterns or limited internal market expertise. It can also help when an organisation is evaluating sophisticated procurement structures such as renewable energy PPAs. Ultimately, the decision should reflect whether external expertise can improve the organisation's procurement process, risk management and use of internal resources.

© 2021 Energy Action. All rights reserved. ABN 90 137 363 636
Contact Us
crosschevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram